Theme: We should prohibit students from working part time jobs
Moderator: Carol
Panelists: Finnian, Hanna, Kofy, Lucus, Allie
Opinions by agree side
Finnian: I think students have to concentrate on study and club activity. If students do part time jobs, they may use money to hung out with their friends. I worry about that point.
Hanna: I also think studying is very important for students. If they do part time jobs, they may not go to school not study. And also, they will oppose to their parents.
Kofy (me): I think it's important not only to study but also reading books, because it makes students' sensitivity rich and they can get a lot of knowledge from books. I worry their reading time will be lost because of part time jobs.
Opinions by disagree side
Lucus: I don't go to school now because I don't have enough money. Like me, some students can't go to school if we prohibit working part time jobs.
Allie: Students can learn a lot of things from part time jobs, such as making friends or helping their family's income. I think studying is important, but they should learn more things through part time jobs.
Discussion
Carol: What do you think about Lucus's opinion?
Finnian: The situation like Lucus is rare. If we permit doing part time jobs, many students use money to hung out with their friends, and they come not to give money to their parents. I worry about that.
Lucus: Parents should manage their money.
Kofy: I worry about their reading or studying time will be short.
Allie: Students can concentrate on studying in short time.
Kofy: If so, they can't understand the contents completely.
Allie: Then, they can study and ask some questions to their teacher at school.
Finnian: However, they must be tired because they do part time jobs, so they may fall asleep.
Lucus: It's as same as club activity. They may fall asleep too.
Haana: What's the purpose of doing part time jobs?
Lucus: I don't think they have to do part time jobs.
Allie: They can help their family's income.
Questions and suggestion by audience
Mac: there are some students who don't have enough money. Do they have to give up going to
school? Are there any supporting system?
Carol: There are no supporting system by the government.
Sophie: I think students who can't go to school can't study at all.
Hanna: The government can support them using scholarship.
Emily: I think some students want to get jobs after graduating, so they don't have to study so much.
Finnian: But they can't get jobs without studying.
Robert: Junior high school is public, but high school is elective, so you can't think of them together.
Kofy: You're right. We want to focus on only junior high school students.
Robert: And also, you need to decide the types of part time jobs.
2nd discussion
Carol: We want to talk about time and type of part time jobs, and students' age.
Allie: Before school is good.
Finnian: Doing by 10:00 p.m. is good, and we don't have to decide age.
Sophie: How about making a part time job club?
Finnian: I think making a part time job board is good too.
Conclusion
Students have to get permission from their parents and teachers. We want to make a part time job club and board.
My opinion
The moderator, Carol did a great job! I'm thankful to her for her work as a moderator. As Robert said, our voices were small. I feel sorry for the audience about not listening our discussion clearly. I think its because I didn't have confidence when I said, so next time, I want to speak my opinions with confidence.
True, you and some panelists voiced smaller.
返信削除But, even so we could hear what you say if you said your idea clearly.
Good job.
I'm sure you spoke more times than before. You couldn't talk because the moderator didn't notice you raising your hand So I think You don't have to raise your hand every time you tell your idea.
返信削除I was convinced of your idea! But, we couldn't say the difference of part-time jobs and club activities.
返信削除Your opinion from your occupation was very understandable! As you said, if you could speak louder, it would be better!
返信削除I thought you had very good idea based on your job!! So I want you to have confidence.
返信削除このコメントは投稿者によって削除されました。
返信削除You always tell us your opinions in terms of occupation, so I really agree with you! You should have confidence!!
返信削除I think it would be better if you had more confidence to say your opinion since you had some good ones in the discussion.
返信削除Since you have nice ideas, I wanted to hear your ideas more.
返信削除Your opinion as a novelist was good. If you have more confidence, it would be better.
返信削除You said your opinions from your occupation's point of view, and it was that nobody could say without you, so it was good. However I wanted you to speak more loud, I expect you next time.
返信削除You didn't often comment in the duscussion, though I felt your opinion was persuasive.
返信削除You had many good opinions, so I should have listened to you more. Thank you!
返信削除You thought about almost all student's position. And you said the opinion with your experience so it is strong!
返信削除Your opinion was based on your childhood so it's strong. At the middle of the discussion, the topic changed a little, however you said a lot of ideas so it's very good.
返信削除your opinions were strong because you talked about your experience. I think you did a good job.
返信削除You always use understandable English, so I think everyone can understand easily.
返信削除Sometimes your explanation didn't get right to the point. I wanted to say 'that is?' many times. But you tried to say your opinion, that's very important.
返信削除